Skip to content
Order online for delivery or pick up • Over 1500+ 5 Star Reviews
icon-X
Close menu
Order Online
Dessert Boxes
Cakes
Henchmen Cookies
This Week at Butter Mafia
Gift Cards
About Us
account
Log in
instagram
Instagram
Facebook
Cart
icon-X
Close cart
Order note
Your cart is currently empty.
icon-search
Search
icon-hamburger
Site navigation
account
Log in
icon-search
Search
icon-bag-minimal
Cart
Order Online
Dessert Boxes
Cakes
Henchmen Cookies
This Week at Butter Mafia
Gift Cards
About Us
Search
Search
Filter
icon-X
Close menu
Availability
In stock
(23)
Out of stock
(3)
Price
Products
icon-filter
Filter
Sort
Sort
Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sold Out
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
$13.00
Candle
$0.50
Delivery Protection
$5.00
Digital Gift Card
from $15.00
Fantastic for Families - Mafia Family Pack
$165.00
Gift Wrapping
$7.00
Gluten Free Cheesecake - Baked Cheesecake "The Secretary"
from $70.00
Gluten Free Cheesecake - Burnt Butter Biscuit New York Cheesecake "The Secretary" 6 or 12 Box
from $55.00
Gluten Free Chocolate Mud Cake with Raspberry Pâte - Mob Wife 6 or 12 Box
from $55.00
Gluten Free Dairy Free Peanut Butter Choc Chunk Cookies - Henchmen Cookie Packs
from $40.00
Gluten Free Dessert Bar 6 Packs
from $50.00
Hedgehog (Plant Based) "Head Honcho" - In Store Only
$9.50
Henchmen Cookie Dairy Free Peanut Butter Cookie - IN STORE ONLY
$7.00
Just like a Gluten Free Lemon Tart - The Miss Tress 6 or 12 Box
from $55.00
Lemon Slice (Plant Based) "Lady Assassin" - IN STORE ONLY
$8.50
Lemon Slice (Plant Based) "Lady Assassin" 6 or 12 Box
from $50.00
Mob Wife Chocolate Mud with Raspberry Pâte - IN STORE ONLY
$9.50
Sold Out
Mother's Day High Tea At Home Box
from $105.00
Signature Dessert & Cookie Box | Assorted Gluten Free Bars & Cookies
from $65.00
1
2
icon-chevron
Next
icon-X
"Close (esc)"
icon-chevron-left
icon-X
icon-chevron
icon-X
Products
