Based on 1194 reviews
99%
(1181)
1%
(10)
0%
(1)
0%
(1)
0%
(1)
Valentines dessert box

My wife loved it, best brownies full stop.it takes us 40 plus minutes to drive there but worth it.
Can't recommend enough.

Gluten free heaven!

Please please try this box of absolute heaven. The best part about it is feeling normal again- being able to indulge in sweet treats just like everyone else- because they are so enjoyable and “normal”! This will make sense to every coeliac who reads this. Thanks again for allowing me to feel good about food and not lose faith in the foody world!!! Xxx

Whole experience was amazing!

Ken was so so lovely
I had ordered a special valentines box for my husband who only recently discovered his gluten sensitivity
He was blown away by all of the slices/cookies and how good they tasted!
Thanks so much again!!

Beautiful!

This was delicious!

Beautiful!

This was absolutely yummy!

D
Choux - Classic Vanilla & Raspberry
Donna Moloney
Yum!

These are absolutely yummy!

D
The Gang
Dawn Bowers
Delicious for All!

Our whole team loves the treats from Butter Mafia, which we first ordered because of the need for gluten free. One staff member even requests them for their birthday so they can share them with the family too!

Delicious!

I’ll always come back for this perfect mix of passion fruit and lemon. It sits on a vanilla biscuit base with a hint of coconut.
Perfect dessert!

M
The Gang
Mariam Howard
Wouldn’t even know it’s GF!

Tasted so good you couldn’t even tell it was Gluten Free! The slices were a lot smaller than I thought but I still managed to cut each piece into 7, and all 7 of us had a bit of each one was an amazing experience!

Yummy

Great balance of passion fruit to lemon textures great and base sublime

The BEST hidden gem!!

I cannot speak more highly of Butter Mafia. I got the ‘Mob Wife’, ‘Gangsta Brownie’ and ‘The Mistress’ and both myself and my friend who I purchased for were absolutely blown away by all three. I’m not gluten free so was subconsciously comparing it to brownies with gluten and can say with confidence that they were the best brownies I have ever had. Specifically, the ‘Mob Wife’ was to die for. UNREAL and perfection on every level.

Will certainly be making the trip from the other side of town very soon to treat myself & stock up⭐️✨

A
Chocolate Brownie - The Gangsta
Amanda Henderson-Marks
Decadent

We loved this brownie best ever.
Warm alittle in the microwave the best
It’s fudging and the best GF I have had

Great tang!

Full passionfruit explosion. Not too sweet. melt in mouth biscuit. Delicious

S
Choux Vanilla
Sue Rasmussen
creamy choux

love my afternoon treat of creamy vanilla choux cant miss it when I get my chicken toastie @ dandy market best reasons to visit

the gangsta

always love it when i pick up my favourite brownie, so rich and yummy cant fault it

Oh so delicious!

The Secretary was everything the other reviews said it would be. Base was yummo, cheesecake filling smooth and decadent, and the topping was so delicious.
My only surprise was how small the cake was for the price I had paid!
Definitely would not have fed 5-6 of my people, so I had to go out and buy another non gluten free cheesecake to serve my other guests!

THE BEST LEMON SLICE

Words cannot express how delicious the lemon slice is! And I would know as it is my favourite dessert. It was exactly the right consistency and sweetness with the perfect lemon tang. Every bite left me wanting more. Perfectly baked and iced. Well done, I will be back.

M
Choux - Classic Vanilla & Raspberry
Marisa
A creamy indulgence

My daughter ordered this and gave it her stamp of approval – the raspberry cream was very delicious. She was glad she decided to eat it on the spot instead of taking it on the train, as it was a bit of a messy experience!

M
Toasted Sandwich - 3 Cheese
Marisa
Absolutely delicious

I took my daughter to Dandenong market especially to go to Butter Mafia, and it did not disappoint! The toastie was deliciously cheesy, with bread that tasted like real bread. Would definitely order it again.

J
Lamington Choux
Jo Blake
Best GF pastry

My daughter and I loved these, it was one of the best Gluten pastries I have ever tasted. As it tasted like it was not GF.

J
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Jo Blake
Best GF toastie ever!!

I loved this toastie, best gluten free one I have ever eaten.

Perfect little treat

This truffle is a little beauty and not too sweet. I actually bought it to increase my iron levels as they’re quite low. No kidding! It’s actually a valid explanation since they’re made with high quality cocoa. Now you know too. 😋

H
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Howard Rock
Amazing chicken sandwich!

I was very pleasantly surprised to discover Buttermafia at the Dandenong Market and very much enjoyed a yummy GF chicken toasted sandwich which I would highly recommend!
Howard

Best GF Cheesecake

My partner is Coeliac and we discovered Butter Mafia a few months ago. Never looked back. It's our go-to place for any occasion.

New York Cheesecake for a birthday treat

Cheesecake is a such a treat, and especially for birthdays. Coming across Butter Mafia's New York Cheesecake in their Northcote kitchen was cause for celebration. The crunchy, buttery base and smooth, creamy top was pure heaven!