Skip to content
Order online for delivery or pick up • Pre-orders available up to 8 weeks
  • Bestsellers
    • Dessert Boxes
    • Dessert Bars
    • Gluten Free & Dairy Free
    • Gluten Free, Dairy Free & Low Lactose
    • Gluten Free & Plant Based
    • Nut Free
    • Gift Boxes and Gift Hampers
    • Digital Gift Cards
    • Gifts from $150
    • Gifts from $100
    • Gifts from $50
    • Gifts under $50
  • Gluten Free Brownies
  • Cakes
  • Gluten Free Bread
  • Log in
  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
Cart
Subtotal
$0.00
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.
Your cart is currently empty.
icon-search Search
account Log in icon-search Search icon-bag-minimalCart
  • Bestsellers
    • Dessert Boxes
    • Dessert Bars
    • Gluten Free & Dairy Free
    • Gluten Free, Dairy Free & Low Lactose
    • Gluten Free & Plant Based
    • Nut Free
  • Gifting
    • Gift Boxes and Gift Hampers
    • Digital Gift Cards
    • Gifts from $150
    • Gifts from $100
    • Gifts from $50
    • Gifts under $50
  • Gluten Free Brownies
  • Cakes
  • Gluten Free Bread
Based on 1450 reviews
Write a review
99%
(1433)
1%
(12)
0%
(3)
0%
(1)
0%
(1)
1324
68
J
Gluten Free Savoury Muffins - Corn, Cheese & Jalapeño
JC
Corn, Cheese & Jalapeño Muffin

Very tasty and flavoursome, a great option for the lunchbox

J
Choux Cloud 9
JC
Cloud 9

Mmmm .. so good!

S
Gluten Free Cheesecake - Baked Cheesecake "The Secretary"
Sue Vanheerden
My favorite cheesecake in the World

I live in Los Angeles, and was lucky to find Butter Mafia while on a trip to Melbourne. Now I am obsessed and can't get enough. The cheesecake is my favorite, but honestly everything is delicious. I get sandwiches and brownies and have given them as gifts and now my friends want more. Can't wait to order more.

User picture
S
Gluten Free Cheesecake - Baked Cheesecake "The Secretary"
Sara Pensalfini
A very happy 50th birthday

Impeccable. I had a small gathering and this cake was perfect. Everybody commented on how delicious it was. Your treats make coeliac living a joy. As a special occasion cake it was elegant and so easy to transport. Thank you. Can’t wait to try more of your delicious creations. Sara :)

K
Toasted Sandwich - 3 Cheese
Karen Warner
Awesome food

All food is fantastic. Staff are really helpful. 100% gluten free so very safe for coeliacs.

F
Gluten Free Chocolate Brownie "The Gangsta"
Fatima
Decadent & Delicious

I heated a piece in the microwave and ate it with some ice cream, as recommended by Kenn. Perfection! This block lasted me a week because of how rich it is. But I want another right away.

F
The Secretary Baked Cheesecake Bar - IN STORE ONLY
Fatima
A perfect cheesecake

Cheesecakes are practically my favourite dessert, so I was incredible excited to find a gluten free cheesecake and even more excited when it was just as delicious as I remember the gluten-full cheesecakes were. Highly recommend. I will be buying it again. And again.

A
The Secretary Baked Cheesecake Bar - IN STORE ONLY
Alex M
So good my partner stole it

I left half of my cheesecake in the box to eat later; it was so amazing that I wanted to save it for later.
My partner asked if he could try it. Silly me said ‘sure’.
It was so amazing that he forgot he was ‘trying’ it an I stead age the whole lot.
I was displeased. There may have been words.
I’m not bitter, I’m just disappointed.

S
Gluten Free and Nut Free Assorted Dessert Bars "Girl Gang"
S Parmenter
Girl Gang

Recently bought Girl Gang dessert box for my friend for International Women's Day. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed each of the dessert in this box! It was a massive hit! Loved it as few of my friends are gluten free and nut free and always find it hard to buy some delicious treats for them. I'll definitely be back to buy more boxes and I want to try the cookies

J
Gluten Free Chocolate Brownie with Roasted Macadamias "The Kingpin" Brownie Block
Jess Corrall
Delicious and fudgy

Really yummy brownie made with high quality ingredients. Equally delicious cold or warmed up slightly with ice cream! Such a treat

R
Choux - Berry-Misu
Rita
Berry Magnificent

Berry Magnificent Choux. 😍

C
Choux - Berry-Misu
Courtney
Perfect choux

The Berry-misu choux was so light and delicate, the tart mix of berries was just perfect! I didn't even miss the custard that it used to be filled with, it was just the best combination!

E
The Boss - Black Velvet Brownie, Roasted Hazelnuts, Salted Caramel, Dark Choc Ganache - IN STORE ONLY
E.
Delicious!

This dessert is delicious - like caramel slice on a brownie. Kenn is lovely, and happy to take the time to go through all the dessert options. I’m very happy with these local, coeliac friendly desserts, I’ll definitely be coming back.

J
Henchmen Cookie Dairy Free Peanut Butter Cookie - IN STORE ONLY
Jess Corrall
Best cookie I’ve had in ages!

This was everything you want from a cookie, right balance of sweet and salty and super moreish. My only regret is not buying more. I will definitely be repurchasing

S
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Scott Russell
A must have.

Phenomenal gluten free bread, delicious filling.

You can not go wrong here!

Bring a friend and get one of each toasted sandwich flavour and share!

You'll thank me later.

R
Fantastic for Families - Mafia Family Pack
Ruhaani Bhula
Excellent

Unbelievably good, such a nice variety & all the guests loved, loved, loved these treats.

M
Assorted Dessert Bars & Dairy Free Cookies "Tasting Pack"
Michael Barnes
Taste only equaled by great service

Recently my sons partner who is a Coeliac sufferer recommended Butter Mafia for a birthday desert and I was amazed how good the Dessert Bars (so moist) and Cookies were. I'll definitely be ordering again.

K
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Kath Ferry
Fabulous filling tasty lunch!

Bread which is tasty, with ingredients to match, thoroughly enjoyed my gf lunch fix!

E
The Kingpin Pack
Emma Pollock
Delicious!

Butter Mafia have done it again. Their desserts are consistently delicious! Thrilled with my purchases. It matters so much to me to be able to order from a reputable establishment and for there to be no compromise in the taste or quality in their gluten free products!

P
Lychee Choux
Pete
It had to be Choux

I'm a lychee enthusiast so I had to try the special Lychee Choux (though the cabinet display still made the decision a tricky one). After politely ignoring my gross mispronunciation of the word Choux, Kenn proceeded to fill the Lychee Choux fresh on the spot. As a result, the outer shell was crisp and not soggy, and the lychee filling creamy with a subtle lychee sweetness. Delicious overall.

T
The Gang
Tess Gardner
Holy moly....

I've been diagnosed coeliac for 8 years and have never had desserts THIS good!
The chocolates are deep and creamy, the citrus is strong and zesty, the crusts are buttery and (for a gluten free biscuit) robust!
Do yourself (maybe not your waistline!) a favour and give these a go!

A
The Gang
Angela Belli
Loved the Gang

OMG we were fighting over them. Delicious and couldn't stop at one.

K
Lemon Slice (Plant Based) "Lady Assassin" 6 or 12 Box
Kat Polhill
Possibly my new favourite

I did not expect to like this better than the Boss, but honestly the flavour and texture are just so damned good... old school lemon slice vibes with 21st century dietaries met!

K
The Boss - Black Velvet Brownie, Roasted Hazelnuts, Salted Caramel, Dark Choc Ganache - IN STORE ONLY
Kat Polhill
Earns the title of Boss of the bunch

So good... rich and moreish with a perfect balance of sweetness. Fab at room temperature and a different vibe again when chilled.

S
Lemon Slice (Plant Based) "Lady Assassin" - IN STORE ONLY
S Dowling
Delightful

Just like old-school lemon slice, only the icing is a bit lighter and airier, which makes for a great contrast with the dense base. A perfect treat with a cup of tea.

About Us

  • The Butter Mafia Story
  • Deliveries and Store Pick Ups
  • Locations and Trading Hours
  • Gluten Free Toastie & Choux Pop Up Northcote Sat 21st March
  • Dandenong Market Menu
  • Gluten Free Blog
  • Butter Mafia VIP Gang
  • Coeliac Awareness Week & March Celebration Giveaway
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us

Support

  • FAQs
  • Ordering and Delivery Information
  • Regional Victoria Delivery Information
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Gift Card Terms

Butter Mafia Locations

BUTTER MAFIA DANDENONG*

Pantry Section, Shop P16, Dandenong Market, Corner Clow St & Cleeland St, Dandenong VIC 3175

Fridays and Saturdays - 8.30am to 4pm*

Tuesdays and Sunday - 9am to 4pm*

*May close earlier when sold out

Please note that Choux Pastries and GF Savouries are only available at our Dandenong Market Shop and at our Special Northcote Pop Ups.

BUTTER MAFIA NORTHCOTE

We are open to the public and welcome walk ins.

Unit 25, 148 Arthurton Rd, Northcote VIC 3070

Monday to Friday - 9am to 4pm

Northcote Gluten Free Toastie & Choux Pop Up

Saturday 21st March 10am - 1pm

  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook

Currency

  • Australia (AUD $)
  • New Zealand (NZD $)
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Union Pay
  • Visa
© 2026 Butter Mafia Powered by Shopify
Butter Mafia Reviews