Skip to content
Order online for delivery or pick up • Over 1500+ 5 Star Reviews
    • Shop Gluten Free
    • Everyday Gluten Free
    • Dessert Boxes
    • Cakes
    • Henchmen Cookies
  • This Week at Butter Mafia
  • Gift Cards
  • About Us
  • account Log in
  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
Cart
Subtotal
$0.00
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.
Your cart is currently empty.
icon-search Search
Butter Mafia Butter Mafia Butter Mafia Butter Mafia
account Log in
icon-search Search icon-bag-minimalCart
  • Order Online
    • Shop Gluten Free
    • Everyday Gluten Free
    • Dessert Boxes
    • Cakes
    • Henchmen Cookies
  • This Week at Butter Mafia
  • Gift Cards
  • About Us
Based on 1597 reviews
Write a review
99%
(1576)
1%
(15)
0%
(3)
0%
(1)
0%
(2)
1470
68
S
Signature Gluten Free Dessert Box | Assorted Dessert Bars
Samantha Francis
Amazing treats & customer service

The sweet treats were absolutely amazing for a work birthday. Everyone complimented them. The customer service was also absolutely amazing, being absolutely accommodating and conscious of when we needed the treats by. Would highly recommend!

K
Henchmen Cookie Dairy Free Peanut Butter Cookie - IN STORE ONLY
Kate Ryan
You’d never know it’s GF

So good that you’d never know it’s gluten free - said by someone who’s not GF!

A
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
Adriana Phillips
Absolutely Delicious 🤤 Butter Mafia

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely Fantastic – Butter Mafia Gluten-Free Bread!

If you’re looking for delicious gluten-free bread, I can highly recommend Butter Mafia! The bread is fantastic, and it’s wonderful to find a product made with such care and quality.

A special mention to Ken, the owner, who is absolutely fantastic! His passion, friendly nature and dedication to his customers make the whole experience even better. It’s clear he takes great pride in what he does.

Supporting a business with such a wonderful product and an equally wonderful owner is a pleasure. Keep up the amazing work, Ken! You have a winning product, and I wish you and Butter Mafia every success. ❤️ Anna Phillips

S
Gluten Free Savoury Muffins - Three Cheese
Samantha Thatcher
The most incredible muffins

The most incredible muffins Ive ever had that in my life!

M
Bread and Butter Pudding
Mary-Anne Ellis
Disappeared quickly

The grandchildren loved the choc chip bread and butter pudding. I was lucky to get some.

M
Banana Maple Walnut Cake Slice
Mary-Anne Ellis
So delicious and crunchy

So delicious and crunchy. The best banana cake ever.

S
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
Simon G
Never had soft, white GF bread like it

Perfect for jaffles and toasties, as well as fresh sandwiches too. Thanks, Butter Mafia!

L
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
Lyne Harrison
Not great

Love all your other items so much - but the bread falls well short of commercially available brands (eg. Abbots- I love their Soy&Linseed)
It wasn’t so long ago you couldn’t get any edible gf bread from the supermarket and baking yr own was the only way. We are now spoilt for choice! So sorry for this neg review - but thanks for trying!

C
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
Cindy Shelley
Yummy

Great bread, makes the most delicious crunchy toast.

F
Bread and Butter Pudding
Fatima
Choc-alicious

I loved the sultana version but it was made even better with the choc chips! The chocolate was so decadent and made it all the more sweeter. Absolutely will have again and would recommend.

C
Henchmen Cookie Dairy Free Peanut Butter Cookie - IN STORE ONLY
Cassie Webb
Best present

My friend loves these as she is gluten free and they're perfect for my partner too as he is dairy free and happens to love peanut butter (and chocolate)! Buying these for them earns me quite a few brownie points ☺️

F
Beetroot, Feta & Walnut Gluten Free Savoury Muffin
Fiona Waters
Savoury treat with crunch

This is a well balanced savoury delight with a little crunchof the nuts. Highly recommended.

S
Basque Cheesecake
Simon G
Goxoa!

After a week in Basque Country this winter, I thought I’d sampled the best of Basque cheesecake (taking some chances with gluten along the way). Coming home to Northcote to find Butter Mafia’s genuinely GF Basque cheesecakes on the menu would have been a nice way to relive those culinary memories. Or that was the plan — until the first bite proved the team had outdone the (alleged) ‘best’ cheesecakes of Bilbao and Donostia/San Sebastián. Thankfully for the Basques, Kenn hasn’t yet expanded into a full pintxos menu, so there’s still reason to go.
I’ve had two of these already and hope to have a third soon :P

R
Signature Dessert & Cookie Box | Assorted Gluten Free Bars & Cookies
Rebecca
Yummo

Beautifully made and absolutely delicious! Highly recommend.

S
Gluten Free Savoury Muffins - Three Cheese
Stephen McNeight
Great muffins so fluffy and moist

Great muffins so fluffy and moist. Brilliant staff who are super friendly and helpful

User picture
M
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
Monica Parravicini
Best gluten free bread

Thanks Buttermafia. Have tried many gluten free breads. These guys have nailed it. Delicious pre sliced gluten free breads!!!!!!!

A
Basque Cheesecake Slice
Anonymous
Delicious!

Delicious!

S
Butter Mafia GF White Bread Loaf
Samantha Farrow
Delicious Loaf

This white loaf of bread is simply delicious. It makes fantastic sandwiches and does not fall apart. It is great in the toaster and last but certainly not least it freezes perfectly. I just love it. Thanks BM for making another awesome product. 💖

F
Basque Cheesecake
Fatima
Just perfection

This was absolutely delicious. The whole family really enjoyed it. Creamy and the perfect amount of sweetness. I would buy it again and again.

C
Gluten Free Savoury Muffins - Three Cheese
Cheyenne Langan
Cheese heaven

I'm pretty sure actual witchcraft was used here, because these muffins are so insanely light and fluffy despite being so full of cheese! The cheese flavour is insane, and my only regret is that I didn't buy more!

C
Henchmen Cookie Dairy Free Peanut Butter Cookie - IN STORE ONLY
Cheyenne Langan
SO. YUMMY!!!

This is the perfect cookie: slightly crisp, slightly chewy, moist without breaking apart, and FULL of chocolatey peanutbuttery goodness. I don't even like peanuts and I loved these cookies. Buy a 12 pack, you'll need them all!

C
Basque Cheesecake Slice
Cheyenne Langan
Crack in cake form

It's been over a week since I had this and I can't stop thinking about it. It was the absolute best cheesecake I've ever had, and I say this as a person mildly obsessed with cheesecake. I have eaten cheesecake all over the world, and this cheesecake is HANDS DOWN the best I've ever had. I crave it every minute of the day. Even the current cost of petrol won't stop me from driving an hour each way to get more. It's so good. If you only get one thing from here (which would be a crying shame because all the products are delicious, but if you live in a cruel world where you can only get one thing...) make it the Basque cheesecake!!!

H
Basque Cheesecake
Heather
Amazing

The best basque cheese cake we have ever had. I bought this as a gift and was lucky enough they were in a sharing mood. Divine.

V
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Verrin Stanger

Yummer

M
Basque Cheesecake
Marisa
The best cheesecake!

I purchased a cheesecake for my daughter’s 30th birthday lunch. Everyone agreed that it was the best cheesecake they had ever eaten. I’m from interstate but will definitely make my way back to this magical little shop on future visits. Highly recommend!

About Us

  • The Butter Mafia Story
  • Deliveries and Store Pick Ups
  • Butter Mafia Northcote Trading Hours
  • This Week at Butter Mafia
  • Gluten Free Blog
  • Butter Mafia VIP Gang
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us

Support

  • FAQs
  • Ordering and Delivery Information
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Gift Card Terms

Visit Us

BUTTER MAFIA NORTHCOTE

Unit 25, 148 Arthurton Rd, Northcote VIC 3070

We are open to the public and welcome walk ins.

Tuesday–Friday – 9am to 4pm

Saturday – 10am to 1pm

Online order pickups – Monday to Saturday

Savoury Muffin Fridays

Fresh from the oven from 11am until sold out

Toasties & Choux Saturdays

Gluten free toasted sandwiches, freshly filled choux pastries, savoury muffins and filter coffee.

Toasties and choux are only available in Northcote during Toastie & Choux Saturdays.

  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook

Currency

  • Australia (AUD $)
  • New Zealand (NZD $)
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Union Pay
  • Visa
© 2026 Butter Mafia Powered by Shopify
Butter Mafia Reviews