Assorted Dessert Bars & Dairy Free Cookies "Tasting Pack"
- In stock, ready to ship
- Backordered, shipping soon
- 100% Gluten Free
- Flavour Guarantee
Mafia Tasting Pack
A Little Bit of Everything. Zero Regret.
Can’t choose just one?
You don’t have to.
The Mafia Tasting Pack is your all access pass to Butter Mafia — a curated hit list of our most loved gluten free dessert bars, plus two of our cult favourite Henchmen Cookies.
It’s generous. It’s varied. It feels like saying yes to yourself.
Perfect for gifting, sharing (if you must), or discovering your future favourites, this pack delivers contrast, balance, and indulgence in every bite — rich, zesty, nostalgic, bold.
What’s Inside
Bestsellers Box — 6 Signature Dessert Bars
One of each of our iconic creations:
Mob Wife
Raspberry pâté layered over decadent chocolate mud — bold, rich, and unapologetic.
The Miss Tress
Tangy lemon and passionfruit curd baked on vanilla biscuit and finished with fine coconut. Bright, fresh, and perfectly balanced.
Lady Assassin
An old school, plant based lemon slice that’s clean, sharp, and quietly dangerous.
Head Honcho
Plant based chocolate hedgehog with gold dusted Maldon salt flakes. Nostalgia, upgraded.
Bad Boy Brownie*
Valrhona chocolate brownie loaded with roasted almonds. Classic, indulgent, no shortcuts.
The Boss*
Our signature black velvet brownie — walnuts, luscious salted caramel, and smooth dark chocolate ganache. Big energy.
2 × Henchmen Cookies
A customer favourite for a reason.
These are not polite cookies.
They’re thick, loaded, and unapologetically rich — peanut butter dough packed with hand cut chocolate chunks, then topped with even more before baking.
Each cookie is hand scooped, weighed, pressed, and finished individually. One is rarely enough. Two is the right call.
Why You’ll Love It
-
A complete Butter Mafia experience in one box
-
Fully gluten free, made in our Coeliac Australia Accredited Kitchen
-
Perfect balance of chocolate heavy, citrusy, nostalgic, and indulgent flavours
-
Ideal for gifting, sharing, or finding your go-to favourite
The Smart Choice
If you’re new to Butter Mafia — start here.
If you already love us — this is how you commit.
Size
Desserts Bars - 8 x 3 x 3cm
Henchmen Cookies - 9+cm in diameter
Brownie Blocks - 11.5 x 9.5 x 3cm (Boozy Bad Boy, Kingpin & OG Bad Boy); 11.5 x 9.5 x 2.5cm (Gangsta)
Sizes are approximate
Care Guide
Best stored refrigerated in an air tight container.
Store Henchmen Cookies on their own (separately from Dessert Bars) as our Henchies absorb moisture.
ShelBest consumed within:
Dessert Bars - 7 days
Henchmen Cookies - 10 days
Brownie Blocks - 14 days
Allergens: Tree Nuts (Almonds, Hazelnuts), Ground Nuts (Peanuts), Eggs, Dairy, Soy and Sulphites
Suitable for Vegetarians. All ingredients used are Halal.
Melbourne & Regional Victoria Deliveries
Next day Melbourne delivery (Monday to Friday) from $12.
Same week Regional Victoria and Greater Melbourne deliveries (order by Tuesday for Thursday or Friday delivery) from $22.
Minimum $45 for delivery orders.
Store Pick Ups
Butter Mafia Dandenong Market
Shop P16, The Pantry, Dandenong Market, Cnr Clow and Cleeland Streets, Dandenong VIC 3175
Tuesdays and Sundays - 9am to 4pm
Fridays and Saturdays - 8.30am to 4pm
Butter Mafia Northcote
Unit 25, 148 Arthurton Rd, Northcote VIC3070
Mondays to Fridays - 9am to 4pm
Interstate Shipping not available due to fragile nature of dessert bars..
