Cart
Your cart is currently empty.
Let customers speak for us
Delicious
I ordered this cake for my husband's birthday, such a yummy gluten free cheesecake that looked beautiful!
Karen Kennedy
Gluten Free Cheesecake - Baked Cheesecake "The Secretary"
So yummy
It’s really amazing how everything here is GF. It doesn’t taste that way, and the same can be said for this choux pastry. The spiced pear paired with the vanilla custard was absolutely perfect. I warmed it up and it was just divine.
Fatima A
Choux - Spiced Pear and Custard
Cheese Heaven
This was delicious! Super cheesy with crispy crunchy bread. I would absolutely buy again. And again.
Fatima A
Toasted Sandwich - 3 Cheese
Deliciousness!
Deliciousness! The sandwich filling is tasty, with just a little bit of celery crunch.
Simone
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Yummy yummy yummy
These are the yummiest muffins - light but tasty and very moreish
Mary-Anne Ellis
Gluten Free Savoury Muffins - Roast Garlic, Feta and Spinach
Best ever
Very light and tasty muffins - best ever
Mary-Anne Ellis
Gluten Free Savoury Muffins - Three Cheese
Delicious
These are mine and my partner's favourite cookies as she is coeliac and I am lactose intolerant. They're amazing!
MISS O Y A DANSO
Gluten Free Dairy Free Peanut Butter Choc Chunk Cookies - Henchmen Cookie Packs
Cheesecake over chocolate, never! Until now...
This cheesecake has exceeded my expectations. When it was first released, I thought I'd give it a try and was blown away by how creamy it is with the perfect biscuit base. When asked what my favourite bar was when recently in store, I couldn't believe that I was saying the secretary cheesecake, when there are so many delicious chocolate dessert bars.
Clare G
The Secretary Baked Cheesecake Bar - IN STORE ONLY
The Best GF Cakes!!!!
This Tetris cake "The Cartel" is AMAZING!!!! Every slice in this box taste's so good!! I will definitely be purchasing this again. 10/10
Suzie Donnelly
The Cartel "Tetris Cake"
Perfect gift for my granddaughter's birthday
I ordered from Butter Mafia for my coeliac granddaughter's birthday while sitting at my computer desk in Lincolnshire England. As she lives in Melbourne I had to take a risk as to how good the quality would be. I need not have worried as she said that everything was delicious and was delivered on time.
Claire Irene Hoskins
Butter Mafia
Scones for the win
So great to be able to partake in scones, which I haven't had for years! Great taste from Butter Mafia - my non gf friends didn't even realise! Nice work.
Judi Benney
Scone
Miss tress lemon passionfruit slice
Always delicious no one would know they are gluten free too good to share
Mavis McGee
The Miss Tress Lemon & Passionfruit - IN STORE ONLY
Tasted amazing all my family members who don’t
Tasted amazing all my family members who don’t need to eat gluten free agree very yummy
Mavis McGee
Toasted Sandwich - Chicken
Surprising Find
Seeing a pop up ad for the cake, I purchased it online & picked up on Mother's Day- it was a delicious addition to our celebrations- carefully crafted & packaged.
Jen
The Cartel "Tetris Cake"
Best Gluten Free treats in Melbourne!
I have purchased several times from Butter Mafia after a recent family celiac diagnosis. The slices and scones are all voted 10/10 from GF and even non GF family members! We love them all! The burnt butter base cheesecake is amazing! Easy pick up or hand delivered gift wrapped boxes was nice too. Thanks Kenn!
KJ
Mother's Day High Tea At Home Box