The Right Choice. With Extra Cookies.
This pack exists for a simple reason:
Two cookies were never enough.
The Mafia Classics Pack delivers the full Butter Mafia experience — our most loved dessert bars paired with a generous stack of Henchmen Cookies. It’s the same hit list as the Mafia Tasting Pack, just turned up where it matters most.
Comforting. Indulgent. Dependable.
This is the box you order when you want to feel prepared — not restrained.
Perfect for first timers, confident repeat customers, and anyone who believes dessert should feel abundant.
One of each of our iconic creations:
Mob Wife
Raspberry pâté layered over decadent chocolate mud. Bold and rich.
The Miss Tress
Tangy lemon and passionfruit curd on vanilla biscuit, finished with fine coconut.
Lady Assassin
An old school, plant based lemon slice — sharp, clean, nostalgic.
Head Honcho
Plant based chocolate hedgehog finished with gold dusted Maldon salt flakes.
Bad Boy Brownie*
Valrhona chocolate brownie packed with roasted almonds. A classic done properly.
The Boss*
Black velvet brownie loaded with walnuts, luscious salted caramel, and smooth dark chocolate ganache. Heavyweight indulgence.
A café favourite for a reason.
Thick, flourless peanut butter cookies fully loaded with chocolate — in the cookie dough and on top. Rich, satisfying, and unapologetically indulgent.
Each cookie is hand scooped, weighed, pressed, and finished individually before baking.
Because one is never enough — and six feels right.
Add one of our brownie blocks and turn your Classics Pack into something legendary:
Kingpin Classics — includes The Kingpin
Our most luxurious brownie. Rich, dark, and generously packed with lightly roasted premium Australian macadamia halves. Once you’ve had The Kingpin, other brownies don’t stand a chance.
Original Classics — includes The Original Bad Boy
The brownie that started it all. A long time crowd favourite loaded with roasted almonds and made exactly the way it’s always been. Reliable. Iconic. Still undefeated.
Gangsta Classics — includes The Gangsta
Pure, smooth, old school chocolate brownie. No nuts. No chunks. No resistance. Built for those who want classic fudgy chocolate without distractions.
A balanced, generous introduction to Butter Mafia
Fully gluten free, made in our Coeliac Australia Accredited Kitchen
Extra cookies for maximum satisfaction
Upgrade options to suit every brownie preference
Some dessert bars and brownie blocks take several days to make and can sell out during busy periods.
If a flavour is unavailable, we’ll replace it with an equally indulgent alternative to keep your pack full and balanced.
Orders are fulfilled on a first-in, best-dressed basis — ordering early is always the smart move.
All Butter Mafia desserts are 100% gluten free and safe for Coeliacs and anyone with gluten sensitivities.
Size
Desserts Bars - 8 x 3 x 3cm
Henchmen Cookies - 9+cm in diameter
Brownie Blocks - 11.5 x 9.5 x 3cm (Boozy Bad Boy, Kingpin & OG Bad Boy); 11.5 x 9.5 x 2.5cm (Gangsta)
Sizes are approximate
Care Guide
Best stored refrigerated in an air tight container.
Store Henchmen Cookies on their own (separately from Dessert Bars) as our Henchies absorb moisture.
ShelBest consumed within:
Dessert Bars - 7 days
Henchmen Cookies - 10 days
Brownie Blocks - 14 days
Allergens: Tree Nuts (Almonds & Walnuts), Ground Nuts (Peanuts), Eggs, Dairy and Sulphites
Suitable for Vegetarians. All ingredients used are Halal.
Melbourne & Regional Victoria Deliveries
Next day Melbourne delivery (Monday to Friday) from $12.
Same week Regional Victoria and Greater Melbourne deliveries (order by Tuesday for Thursday or Friday delivery) from $20.
Minimum $45 for delivery orders.
Store Pick Ups
Butter Mafia Dandenong Market
Shop P16, The Pantry, Dandenong Market, Cnr Clow and Cleeland Streets, Dandenong VIC 3175
Tuesdays and Sundays - 9am to 4pm
Fridays and Saturdays - 8.30am to 4pm
Butter Mafia Northcote
Unit 25, 148 Arthurton Rd, Northcote VIC3070
Mondays to Fridays - 9am to 4pm
Interstate Shipping not available due to fragile nature of dessert bars..
During 40 years on a gluten free diet for coeliac disease, I have eaten a lot of disappointing breads and bakery items. I can confidently say that Butter Mafia will never disappoint! At last there are sweets I can confidently take to dinners and events to share without feeling the need to apologise to the non GF diners; they love them too! But the bread is a miracle. It is easily the best GF bread I have eaten in 40 years. Great work Kenn, thank you!
Purchased some items for a work fairwell - all enjoyed
I accidentally bought a $90 classics box (“accident” meaning that I saw it as an option while I was waiting in line and couldn’t help myself). It was so good that my partner and I finished the whole thing over 2 days and we didn’t even feel bad about it. Everything was delightfully delicious and perfect with a cup of tea or coffee.
Wonderfully delicious products and amazing customer service from Kenn!
Ordered slices and biscuits for my grandmothers birthday afternoon tea. Arrived exactly as scheduled and everyone loved the cakes and biscuits, so tasty!
