Gluten Free Cheesecake Baked Cheesecake New York Cheesecake Cheesecake Shop Gluten Free Gluten Free Bakery Melbourne Northcote Dandenong Dessert Shop Dessert Delivery Melbourne Regional Victoria Coeliac Australia Accredited Birthday Cake Celebration Cake

Made to Order - Gluten Free Cheesecake - Baked Cheesecake "The Secretary" Larger Cake

Regular price$149.00

Cake Size
  • In stock, ready to ship
  • Backordered, shipping soon
  • 100% Gluten Free
  • Flavour Guarantee

Baked Cheesecake with Burnt Butter Cream Cheese Frosting and Burnt Butter Biscuit "The Secretary" (18 x 24cm or 24x36cm made to order only)

The Secretary is our take on the classic New York Cheesecake... with a twist.

We start with the twice baked burnt butter biscuit base which gives you a caramelly nutty aroma together with a buttery crunch. Sitting on top of this is a smooth, creamy dreamy baked vanilla cheesecake. This cheesecake is not too sweet while being creamy and cheesy at the same time.

Just the biscuit base and the cheesecake layer on their own are beautiful (we have these in dessert bars - check them out here) but we wanted to level this up and make it extra special for celebrations.

So we made a burnt butter cream cheese frosting. This is literally the icing on the cake and it is beautiful! Wonderful aromatic nutty notes really come through with each bite and you experience the three different textures - the crunch of the biscuit base, the smooth cheesecake layer and the lush cream cheese frosting.

"The Secretary" is what you'd get if "banoffee pie" and "New York cheesecake" had a love child! And just because, it's accented with edible gold leaf.

Our larger celebration cakes are made to order only. Get in touch with us today to order yours.


    Approximately 18 x 24 x 4.5cm (A) or 24 x 36 x 4.5cm (B)

    Portions: (A) 18 - 24 Cake Serves or (B) 36 - 48 Cake Serves.

    Best stored refrigerated in an airtight container and consumed within 1 week.

    Allergens: Eggs and Dairy

    Suitable for Vegetarians. All ingredients used are Halal.

    Melbourne & Regional Victoria Deliveries

    Next day Melbourne delivery (Monday to Friday) from $10.

    Same week Regional Victoria and Greater Melbourne deliveries (order by Tuesday for Thursday or Friday delivery) from $20.

    Minimum $45 for delivery orders.

    Store Pick Ups

    Butter Mafia Dandenong Market

    Shop P16, The Pantry, Dandenong Market, Cnr Clow and Cleeland Streets, Dandenong VIC 3175

    Tuesdays and Sundays - 9am to 4pm

    Fridays and Saturdays - 8.30am to 4pmORButter Mafia

    Butter Mafia Northcote

    Unit 25, 148 Arthurton Rd, Northcote VIC3070

    Mondays to Fridays - 9am to 4pm

    Interstate Shipping not available due to fragile nature of dessert bars.

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 13 reviews
    Gino Fulco

    Absolutely delicious! The entire family devoured this cheesecake. Highly recommend to everyone

    Mafia Magic

    The Secretary is superbly presented and the taste brings me back to old school recipes of buttery thick biscuit bases, delectable cheese cake texture topped with a not sweet but just right topping. I have no special dietary requirements but Butter Mafia are my go to sweets. I tried many and never been disappointed. Thanks Kenn and team

    Deliciously moreish

    What a cracker of a cake, everyone was raving about it at my partners birthday. Would get it again, would love to try more flavours also!

    M B
    Gone in seconds!

    This cake was so good! The cheesecake base is unbelievable for a GF cake, the presentation was gorgeous and it was gone at the party in seconds. Can’t recommend highly enough!

    Best Birthday Cake Ever!

    I ordered The Secretary for my birthday and it was wonderful! Probably the best birthday cake I've had in years!

    Having been very impressed by the strawberry version (Please bring it back!), I didn't hesitate to order the Secretary for my birthday this year, which was the best decision I made.

    True to past experience, I am never disappointed with Butter Mafia treats, and I am an avid fan of everything they offer!