Signature Gluten Free Dessert & Cookie Box | Assorted Bars & Cookies
- In stock, pre-order for store pick up
- Backordered, shipping soon
- 100% Gluten Free
- Flavour Guarantee
Butter Mafia Box
The full Butter Mafia experience — bars and cookies, side by side.
A curated mix of our most loved gluten free dessert bars and Henchmen Cookies, made for when you want a little bit of everything.
No choosing. No second guessing.
Just an easy, generous box of Butter Mafia favourites.
Made for Coeliacs. Loved by everyone.
100% gluten free. Coeliac Australia Accredited.
Choose Your Experience
⭐ Full Experience
6 assorted dessert bars + 6 Henchmen Cookies.
More to share. Better value. The full Butter Mafia experience.
Lite
6 assorted dessert bars + 2 Henchmen Cookies.
A smaller taste of everything.
What’s Inside
Your Butter Mafia Box is thoughtfully packed as two separate boxes — one for dessert bars and one for cookies — so each item arrives in perfect condition.
Dessert Bars
Mob Wife
Raspberry layered over rich chocolate mud — bold, rich, and unforgettable.
The Miss Tress
Lemon and passionfruit curd on vanilla biscuit, finished with coconut — bright and punchy.
Lady Assassin (Plant Based)
Classic lemon slice — clean, sharp, nostalgic.
The Secretary
Burnt butter biscuit baked cheesecake — rich, creamy, and deeply satisfying.
The Gangsta (Gangsta Brownie)
Valrhona chocolate brownie — dense, fudgy, and unapologetically chocolate.
Each box includes a double of one of our most loved bars — most often our baked cheesecake — because one is never enough.
Henchmen Cookies
Packed separately to keep their crisp edges and chewy centres just right — made to be just as addictive as the bars.
Why You’ll Love It
- Bars and cookies packed separately for the best texture and quality
- Perfect if you want a little bit of everything in one easy order
- Great for gifting, sharing, or keeping stocked at home
- No flavour decisions — we’ve chosen the favourites for you
Important Notes
- Dessert bar flavours may vary slightly depending on availability
- Any substitutions are made to maintain the same balance and quality
- You may receive doubles of selected favourites
- Pre-ordering is recommended during busy periods
100% Gluten Free
Made in our Coeliac Australia Accredited kitchen, with strict processes in place to ensure safety for Coeliacs and anyone avoiding gluten.
Allergens: Dairy, Eggs, Soy (Lady Assassin Lemon Slice) and Sulphites (The Miss Tress Lemon and Passionfruit and Lady Assassin Lemon Slice) and Ground Nuts (Peanuts in Henchmen Cookies).
Suitable for Vegetarians. All ingredients used are Halal.
Suitable for Vegetarians. All ingredients used are Halal.
Melbourne & Regional Victoria Deliveries
Next day Melbourne delivery (Monday to Friday).
Same week Regional Victoria and Greater Melbourne deliveries (order by Tuesday for Thursday or Friday delivery).
Minimum $45 for delivery orders.
Store Pick Ups
Butter Mafia Dandenong Market
Shop P16, The Pantry, Dandenong Market, Cnr Clow and Cleeland Streets, Dandenong VIC 3175
Tuesdays and Sundays - 9am to 4pm
Fridays and Saturdays - 8.30am to 4pm
Butter Mafia Northcote
Unit 25, 148 Arthurton Rd, Northcote VIC3070
Mondays to Fridays - 9am to 4pm
Interstate Shipping not available due to fragile nature of dessert bars..
